Star Trek Voyager Reviews Written by Someone Who Actually LIKES the Show! -- Eye of the Needle


Hello there and welcome to another exciting Star Trek Voyager review! This time we're going to look at "Eye of the Needle." I'm going to be giving away tons of spoilers as well as my own personal opinion of the show I like so much. So if Romulans and wormholes and people who need their own space aren't your thing, why not go somewhere a bit more earth-bound?

For instance, the MSNBC News Index.

No dice? All right then...

INITIAL VIEWER EXPERIENCE
A wormhole that works would mean the end of the series, but this is all still pretty interesting...Yea! more on the Doctor!...even more on the Doctor!...More on the wormhole!...Aw, will Voyager's luck never improve?...Even more on the Doctor!

PLOT
Voyager has found signs of a possible wormhole and eagerly investigates, only to discover that the wormhole is very, very old and so has collapsed down to microscopic size. The Voyager's a mite too big, but Kim sends in a microscopic probe to see where the wormhole leads. Traveling through the collapsed currents, the probe gets stuck in a gravitational attraction and can't work its way out. That would seem to be it...except that something on the other side of the wormhole scans the probe. What can this mean?

Baxter, who looks too wimpy to be a security officer, gets treated for a pulled muscle by the Doctor. The guy doesn't speak directly to the Doctor, but directs comments about him to Kes. Baxter leaves and Kes worries about how people are treating her mentor.

Kim and Torres discuss going home. Kim can't wait to get back to his girlfriend, Libby, but Torres knows there's no one waiting for her anxiously back in the Alpha Quad.

Kes sees Janeway in her ready room and drinks some Godawful drink with spinach in it. Janeway's vegetable bouillon explains why she's such a rail. Anyway, Kes wants everyone to treat the Doctor better. Just because he's a program doesn't mean he should get no respect. Janeway thinks about it.

Kim and company manage to get a signal through to the person who scanned their probe. It's a Romulan! (Right quadrant, wrong neighborhood.) Janeway tries to get him to understand that they're stuck in the Delta Quadrant and have rigged up two dixie cups and a string through a microscopic wormhole. Nonsense, says the Romulan guy. They must be spies out to get him. Then he hangs up.

Janeway orders Kim to get him back and stomps off the bridge...to see the Doctor. When she points out that he's become a full-blown member of the crew, he worries that she's going to want to change his program. Instead, she asks if there's anything she can do to help him be the chief medical officer. He's got an answer for her right away, "What I'd like is to be turned off when people leave!" She offers him control over his own on-off switch, and suddenly new vistas of possibility open before his eyes. He says he'll get back to her on what else he'd like.

Janeway's night rest is interrupted by the Romulan guy, who won't give her his name. He thinks she may well be from the Delta Quadrant after all and wants to know what she wants. She says she just wants him to send the Federation the news that they're all alive, and transmit some personal messages from the crew. He says he'll ask permission from Romulus.

Voyager manages to establish a visual link over the probe's signal and our crew gets to lay eyes on the Romulan commander. Surprise! He's got a big forehead, bad hair, and shoulder pads Joan Crawford would have killed for. He says the Voyager's a type of ship he hasn't seen before, but he's been out in space for a good year or so. She says it's not classified, and the whole thing is really quite cordial. An excited Torres reveals that with a bit more work, Voyager could use the signal for a transporter beam. Janeway tells her to get right on it, as the probe will only last inside that wormhole another day or so before getting crushed.

Kes, who is doing very well with her medical studies since she has a photographic memory, relates much of this to the Doctor. He can't go with them, however, as his program is integrated into the ship's systems. She gives him a kiss on the cheek and says she'll always remember him. He asks her a favor. If they do leave, would she remember to turn him off?

The Romulan is super-impressed with Voyager's crew when he learns they might be able to transport over. They couldn't come to his ship or anything, but if it works he'll get a military ship in the area to pick them up. Torres beams over a test cylinder, though there's some strange trouble with a phase shift. They manage this cylinder thing several times, and the next thing they must do is transport a person. The Romulan commander volunteers and, once again with phase shifting difficulty, Torres manages to bring him over.

A triumphant Janeway orders the evacuation right before Tuvok drops the bad news. He asks the Romulan what the date is, and the response is twenty years ago. That phase shift Torres had so much trouble is actually a temporal shift.

In conference, the crew considers their options with the Romulan. He comes up with the idea of preventing Voyager's mission before it starts, but (apart from the fact that this wouldn't help the Maquis at all) Voyager's made quite an impact on this system and other people would be affected by this temporal tom-foolery. Finally Janeway asks him simply to relay the messages as they originally planned. He agrees, and gives them his name: Telek. When they make it back home, he says, please look him up.

Telek is successfully beamed back to his ship, and Janeway takes comfort that at least the messages were sent right before Tuvok drops the bad news. Telek died several years ago. Who knows what happened to those messages? Janeway orders a return to course.

The Doctor tells Baxter to talk to him, not Kes, and Baxter calls him "sir" before scooting out of there. The Doctor asks Kes to give his list of demands...er, requests to Janeway and then asks for one more thing: a name.

CHARACTER
Well, the Doctor is most on display here, though his tale is the subplot. He and Kes make a powerful argument that if Janeway and the rest expect him to act like a member of the crew, they need to treat him that way. We've expected the this argument to arise, I'm sure, for some time now.

What I wasn't expecting, however, was the power of the scene when the Doctor asks Kes to make sure he's turned off if they abandon ship. Now, doubtlessly Janeway would destroy the ship if the crew actually left, but what a chilling image we get here, aided by the lingering shot of the Doctor sitting at his little desk. After all the complaining he's done about being left on in Sickbay without anything to do, we can well believe that being stranded on the ship, unable to turn himself off, is indeed his worst possible nightmare.

The request for a name is somewhat pale beside this, but it certainly makes sense that he's getting tired of "Hey, you." I just hope they don't name him after Zimmerman [I read in a couple places they are going to], since he doesn't look like a Zimmerman to me. I think "Fred" is more what I'd go for. You got a name to suggest? E-mail me!

I'm sure Janeway's nightgown is supposed to tell us about her character, but I already knew that she's a woman, so I'll just leave it for SPECTACLE.

THOUGHT
I have to admit, this is the sort of episode I've been dreading, but it worked out pretty well. In fact, in some ways "Eye of the Needle" may well be my favorite non-pilot episode so far.

The problem is that it's one of those "Oh look! we're going to get home...no we're not" episodes. If they have many of these it's going to get old really, really quick.

But this time around it works very nicely. Some of the things which help include that we get real obstacles to overcome: the wormhole's size, the Romulans' paranoia, the use of the transporter, and so on. When that strange phase shift turns out to be the one they can't overcome, there's no sense of something popping out of the blue to foil our heroes, or yet another sticky moral situation which could be ignored if Janeway would just get off her high horse. No, it's a sensible, believable problem that really does put an end to using the wormhole. If the ship itself could go through, I suppose they might give it a try and hide out for twenty years, but in the Romulans' hands, defenseless, there isn't a chance.

Other good things simply involve good storytelling. The plot moves swiftly and the hint-laden dialogue is on-target with the possible exception of the Kim-Torres exchange, which only confirms what we pretty much already knew about them. Of course, the exchange is also supposed to represent the unification of the Maquis-Starfleet crew, but it could still be a little more interesting.

SPECTACLE
The nightgown is lovely and the wig is a kick.

DICTION
Best line goes once again to the Doctor, though not for the usual reasons:

"Are you suggesting that I be reprogrammed?" -- Doctor revealing to Janeway just how poorly the crew is treating him.


SONG
Real musicians, not canned, turn in another fine performance.

And now for the baggage...

STAR TREK ELEMENTS WE (OR I, ANYWAY) LOVE
Characters who really do challenge our notions of what "personality" and "sentience" mean. Much as I like the Doctor, he's not "real," is he? Treating the Doctor better isn't a matter of recognizing his rights, whatever Kes may think, but of getting a better performance out of him. How many of us feel that we'd do better at work if someone just recognized that we're supposed to be part of a team? Responsibility, not a soul, make the Doctor worthy of a "sir" every now and then, or at least the knowledge that he's not going to be deleted if he steps out of line.

The Romulans are a welcome sight. The show can't do it too often, but the occasional Alpha Quadrant resident will be a treat. After all, the Caretaker was scooping ships up for several months before Voyager got there. Who knows who else is tooling home as fast as they can?

Why not some Pakleds? "We look for things to get us home. We are strong. We are lost."

STAR TREK ELEMENTS WE (OR I, ANYWAY) HATE
Nope. Nothing occurs to me right now. Maybe later.

Okay. That's it for now.

Star Trek Voyager Reviews

Or would you like to go forward to ST Voyager Reviews -- Ex Post Facto?

Or perhaps back to ST Voyager Reviews -- The Cloud?