Star Trek Voyager Reviews Written by Someone Who Actually LIKES the Show! -- Flashback


All right then, this is a review containing many spoilers of the Star Trek Voyager episode, "Flashback." It is intended solely for the nostalgic enjoyment of Voyager, Sulu, and Janice Rand fans. Those who don't like watching worlds collide or serrilium ignite are encouraged to find their jollies elsewhere.

How about Animated Greeting Cards?

No? Okay then...

INITIAL VIEWER EXPERIENCE
"Trials and Tibble-ations" this ain't, but it's fun to see Sulu and Rand and get a tangent story to Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Profit...How odd it would be to live so long, Vulcan or not....The idea of the virus is really cool.

PLOT
Neelix starts his day the usual way, annoying the heck out of Tuvok, who really just wants something that won't make him sick. Janeway calls them both to the bridge because the ship has found a nebula that contains a highly prized energy source, serillium. Tuvok takes one look at this nebula and feels even worse than he would have from Neelix's breakfast. He goes to Sickbay, but is assaulted by a strange childhood memory of holding a screaming girl over a precipice. "Don't let me go, Tuvok!" she screams. Little Tuvok tries, but she slips from his hands and screams on the way down. Big Tuvok collapses in Sickbay from the realization he's just reenacted Stallone's role in Cliffhanger.

The Doctor says it's a panic attack, and since Vulcans aren't prone to fainting spells, he puts a cortical monitor on Tuvok's head. Tuvok meditates for hours while building a kithira, which is basically a Vulcan house of cards that leads to inner peace. Kes thinks it looks cool, but it doesn't seem to help him much.

The next day, Tuvok's fine until he spots that nebula again and talks of Klingons before having another attack. This time the monitor makes it clear that he is suffering from a repressed memory that's trying to get out. Now, if it were you or I, we could just go see Troi on the holodeck [future episode idea??], but repressed memories go against Vulcan mental discipline and therefore can become fatal if not dealt with. Janeway agrees to mind-meld with Tuvok, since she's the closest thing to family he's got on Voyager. With his hands on her face he tries to remember the little girl.

Instead, we go to the bridge of the Excelsior and meet Captain Sulu and Lieutenant Rand as they were eighty years ago. (You remember this from Star Trek VI, right?) Praxis has just exploded and Sulu rides the wave and Kirk is captured and all that. Tim Russ is actually in the movie, too, which makes this all pretty cool if you just ignore the fact that in the film his ears are round.

Anyway, Tuvok can't explain why they are here to Janeway, who appears with him in this flashback [hence the title], but can only be seen by him. While Tuvok makes tea for Sulu and then endures numerous jokes about brown-nosing, he also explains to Janeway that this was his first assignment, though the records have been fudged a bit. He was twenty-nine and not very fond of Starfleet. His parents pushed him into it.

He's so uptight back then, in fact, that when Sulu orders a course through the Azure Nebula to rescue Kirk and McCoy, Tuvok objects. That's the least of his worries, however, for when he catches a glimpse of this Azure Nebula, he sees that little screaming girl go over the cliff again, and the mind-meld breaks up.

The doctor tells Janeway that Tuvok better get this all sorted out soon or he'll be brain dead. Kim compares the two nebulae and tells the captain they have nothing other than a visual similarity. Perhaps, they speculate, that's all that's going on here: some sort of visual trigger to Tuvok's memories.

Janeway and Kim nostalgically discuss the old days and ways of Starfleet.

Tuvok and Janeway try again, and again we are on the Excelsior. Tuvok's bunkmate, Dimitri Valtane, is killed by an explosion at his console, and Tuvok stands over him as he dies. Out comes that little girl and the cliff again. This hurts Tuvok's mind some more, so his memories start becoming real to him. Janeway becomes visible to the other people on the bridge as we basically get a mind-meld version of an hallucination. Sulu has security take her off the bridge.

Janeway doesn't want to leave Tuvok when they're so close to figuring out the connection between Valtane's death and the little falling girl, so they steal Rand's outfit (which really hangs on Janeway!) so she can observe without getting arrested by Sulu's thugs again.

Meanwhile, the damaged mind-meld is causing risk to Janeway, so the Doctor tries to break up the link with thoron radiation. Unexpectedly, this reveals the presence of an ingram which is neither Janeway nor Tuvok's memory ingram. It looks instead to be some sort of virus which is only masquerading as an ingram, kind of like the way Republicans sometimes disguise themselves as Democrats so they can go to the really cool parties. The Doctor pours on the radiation to kill the virus, and it jumps into Janeway's brain instead.

Back on the Excelsior bridge, little Tuvok, and then little Janeway (well, not so little, actually) lose their grip on the falling girl. The Doctor applies radiation to both their brains and we see the virus start to die. The girl falls from some little Eskimo boy's hand, then some alien girl's hand, then some more United Colors of Bennington hands, until, finally, the pesky but PC virus is dead at last.

With Tuvok restored, the Doctor explains that this strange new virus does indeed masquerade as a memory to hide from the body's immune system. It also chooses an unpleasant memory so that the brain will bury the virus deep in the unconscious, where it can roost.

Tuvok wraps up the Star Trek VI plot without ruining the ending for those who haven't seen the video. Tuvok tells Janeway he was glad to have been a part of those times of Kirk and the rest, and Janeway say she feel now like she was a part of them too.

CHARACTER
Tuvok's background is explored here, but we really don't learn too much about him as a person. He joined Starfleet when he was too young, resigned, had his own kids, then went back into service. Janeway also isn't really put on display. She cares for Tuvok, but we knew that one already. The rest of the regulars are just window dressing.

Sulu's character isn't developed much, either. He acts more like Judge Dredd than I would have expected, which makes this the official Voyager-Stallone episode.

It's great to see Rand again.

THOUGHT
Okay, the big strike against this episode seems to be that it's Voyager's offering to the Star Trek 30th Anniversary business, and really does suffer by comparison to "Trials and Tribble-ations" and First Contact. Sulu and Kirk are both basically props in their respective stories, but Kirk has the excuse of being computer-generated.

Let's limit the comparison to one scene each.

In "Trials and Tibble-ations," computer imaging puts Bashir and O’Brien next to Scotty and the other rabble-rousers while Kirk demands to know who threw the first punch. We're amazed to watch the seamless shot as O’Brien actually talks to Kirk. We learn nothing about anyone in this scene, but we get to re-live TOS in a brand-new way. It's not deep; it's a scream!

In "Flashback," there're reconstructed scenes instead of computer images, and it's not as seamless. The scenes don't completely fit into Star Trek VI, though they come close, to be sure. When Sulu speaks to Tuvok, we have no sense of amazement, we just wonder how much money Take got for the gig. So what we should get instead is insight into either Sulu or Tuvok's character. But Sulu's loyalty to Kirk is hardly news, and the Tuvok who needed this lecture is the old Tuvok, or, rather, the young one. We've seen our Tuvok go beyond the call of duty more than once in his loyalty to Janeway (see "Prime Factors," for example). He doesn't need this lecture anymore, nor is it really all that fascinating that he once did.

But comparisons to DS9's tribute aside, "Flashbacks" is hardly the total wash many have claimed. The idea of the virus disguising itself as a repressed memory is an extremely cool way (much better than the Nexus, for example) of bringing the old cast into the picture. They did a lot of work to recreate the Excelsior, and it is fun to look at the old uniforms and everything.

And perhaps if we're not cynical about the Star Trek Anniversary thing, we might notice that Janeway's tribute to the old days of Starfleet has a deeper meaning. She talks about how much bigger space was to Kirk and company, and how much more flexible they had to be about the prime directive as a consequence. They had to be a little faster on the trigger -- a little more arrogant and destructive, in other words, in such hostile territory.

Now, does Janeway realize she's describing herself? This is Voyager's legacy as well: flexible, quick to fight, even compromised, at times. Space is much bigger to them than to, say, the Enterprise E, because they are so far from home. Janeway and Kirk have a lot in common, I'm noticing. She sure does seem to like those phasers.

I also like Tuvok's interactive memories, though I've seen others who don't. Tuvok's brain damage is causing him to be unable to distinguish between what really happened and the fantasy encouraged by Janeway's presence. All the elements mix and mingle while he grows more confused. When she puts on the uniform, she actually looks like a blend of the old and new, trying to keep everything together for Tuvok while he tries to figure out what the girl at the cliff has to do with anything.

SPECTACLE
I've already mentioned the fun of looking at the old ship. Those bunk-beds looked wonderfully primitive, and most uncomfortable for a Vulcan who valued his privacy. What with that and Valtane's death, it's easy to understand why the young Tuvok left Starfleet that first time.

I've got to mention that chubby version of Janeway as a child. Are we going to hear more about this?

DICTION
"Mr. Neelix, I would prefer not to hear the life history of my breakfast." -- Tuvok


SONG
Smooth work on the score, as always. If they did use some of the old music, I didn't notice. Did anyone else?

And now for the baggage...

STAR TREK ELEMENTS WE (OR I, ANYWAY) LOVE
References to Kirk and company always give me a thrill.

I also enjoy the invention of really cool diseases that have to be battled in some way that at least seems to make sense.

STAR TREK ELEMENTS WE (OR I, ANWAY) HATE
I know he's got his dignity and all that, but how could Janeway allow Tuvok to walk on his own to Sickbay? Thank goodness he managed to stagger through the door before he collapsed.

I must say I have a little less awe of Vulcan mental abilities if they can be floored by a repressed memory, though. Seems like one really embarrassing day in junior high could lay waste to a whole family if they're not careful.

Well, that's a wrap!

Star Trek Voyager Reviews

Or go ahead to ST Voyager Revoews -- The Chute.

Or go back to ST Voyager Revoews -- Basics Pt 2.