Star Trek Voyager Reviews Written by Someone Who Actually LIKES the Show! -- Heroes and Demons


Sit by the fire and harken to talk of the Star Trek Voyager episode "Heroes and Demons." This review is full of spoilers and solely intended for the enjoyment of fellow Voyager fans, as well as for the delight of those who know how to swim in their armor for five days before slaying the dread beast. For those of you who just aren't into blood and gore and photonic energy lattices, may I suggest you click on to something else?

How about Find-A-Grave?

What? Still too gory for you? Oh dear, what's a shield maiden to do?

INITIAL VIEWER EXPERIENCE
Oh dear, more trouble in the holodeck...but this is actually pretty fun, and finally gives me some payoff for struggling through that endless poem...What a good adventure for the Doctor...WHAT did you say your name is?...Oh, all right.

PLOT
Janeway and Torres are putting their scientific brains together to study some photonic energy they've found in a protostar. It might help them to boost Voyager's energy efficiency. Beaming up two samples into their containers, however, causes them some trouble. They manage to get their samples in the end, though, and call for Kim to come and help them.

No Kim. No Kim anywhere on the ship. The computer doesn't know where he's gone, and none of the shuttles are missing. They try to look in his last known location, the holodeck, but something weird’s going on in there; they can't even scan it.

Chakotay and Tuvok go to the holodeck, and find that Kim's program of Beowulf, a 6th Century epic poem from Denmark, is playing and won't shut off. The program's command codes aren't working [Can you image that!!] and neither are the safeties [Well, gosh and golly gee! I didn't know that ever happened in a holodeck! You'd think people would stop going into holodecks if they knew things like that could happen!].

Anyway, Chakotay and Tuvok venture into the program, walking through a misty forest at night, and are confronted by Freya, the king's shield maiden. She talks about poor "Beowulf" with his black hair and fiery eyes, and they realize it's Kim. However, "Beowulf" was killed by Grendle and dragged down to his foul lair. Freya is glad Tuvok and Chakotay are here to avenge his death. She takes them to the mead hall to meet the king.

The fear of Grendle oppresses the hall, and the ring-giver is old and tired. Freya calls for Tuvok and Chakotay to be welcomed, but Unferth gets pissy and tries to challenge them. The king says if they want to slay Grendle, it's no skin off his nose, and the holocharacters all retire.

Tuvok and Chakotay report their experience to Janeway, who grabs on to the fact that they haven't yet found a body. She orders them to fix the holodeck's imaging scanner and relay tricorder data.

Chakotay and Tuvok's perfectly lovely discussion of literature is interrupted by "Grendle's" arrival. They tell Janeway they're reading photonic energy as some sort of light starts coming through the door. Tuvok wonders if somehow this disruption of photonic energy has caused the holodeck to dematerialize Kim. The energy intensifies, and though Torres does her best to beam them out, the two officers, like Kim, vanish.

Janeway tells Torres and Paris that the photonic energy she and Torres were working with may have contaminated the holodeck matrix and be causing the computer to convert real matter into energy when Grendle appears. Paris says Kim, Tuvok, and Chakotay's patterns may still be there. They need someone to go in there and study the photonic energy, and the perfect candidate is...the Doctor! He can go in there without worrying about his real matter, because he has no real matter.

Janeway tells the Doctor his data stream will be redirected into the holodeck, and that he'll be able to protect himself from harm by making himself solid or unsolid at will. His mission will be to scan the photonic energy when it shows up.

The Doctor accepts his first away mission with some discomfort, but readily brushes up on his knowledge of Beowulf. Kes gets him to talk about how nervous he is. Not only has he never been on an away mission before, he's never even "seen a sky, or a forest, let alone Vikings and monsters." Kes suggests that he finally decide on his name before he goes on the mission, to make himself feel more like a Starfleet officer.

Paris transfers the Doctor to the holodeck, where he smells a tree. The Doctor goes into the forest and is challenged by Freya, whom he recognizes. She's flattered that he knows of her and asks his name. Proudly, he announces, "Schweitzer...Dr. Schweitzer." On the way to the mead hall, they talk about drinking a broth made from a fungus and whether the Vikings could still beat the Saints if the Saints were given a forty-point lead and the Vikings all had their legs chopped off.

At the mead hall, Unferth is even pissier to the Doctor than he was to Tuvok and Chakotay. In fact, upon hearing from Freya that the Doctor plans to slay Grendle, Unferth tries to cleave our good medical man from the knave to the chops. The Doctor just makes himself unsolid and suggests that Unferth put some ice on the hand he hurt slamming his sword into the stone floor.

Freya calls for all of them to hail Lord Schweitzer and the Doctor digs it.

At a banquet, the Doctor eats elk and recounts the glorious adventure of creating an inoculant against some alien measles. Unferth can hardly stand any of this and finally tells the king it's time to retire.

The Doctor now gets his first groupie (Kes doesn't count) as Freya invites him to her bed and lays a big one on his lips. The Doctor digs it.

Alone, the Doctor watches as "Grendle" approaches in blinding light, a swirl of photonic energy which curls a tentacle around his right arm. "Get me out of here!" he screams, and Paris takes his own sweet time about it, but does retrieve him...all but the arm, that is.

Hey, Doc! Need a hand? HAHAHAHAHA

Paris gets the Doctor back together and Torres studies the data from his tricorder. That photonic energy is showing synaptic patterns. She and Paris go to engineering to see if they can read such patterns in the little samples they have, and one of the samples escapes its containment field and cuts through the ship to escape. Torres and Paris realize it's showing intelligence [I mean, would you want to stay in that containment field?] and Janeway lets it go.

Out in space, the little photonic energy guy flies into an energy lattice which may be some sort of ship for the creature. The ship's sensors also pick up three bio-electrical patterns in the lattice, and Janeway thinks this could be Kim, Tuvok, and Chakotay. Think about it, she says, when Voyager accidentally took intelligent creatures from the protostar and started experimenting on them, perhaps the beings retaliated by taking crewmembers hostage. They fix up the remaining photonic creature in a Tupperware container and give it to the Doctor. He'll have to go in and somehow convince the photonic Grendle that they mean these creatures no harm. He'll also have to stay solid so he can hold on to his Tupperware.

He returns to the holodeck and Freya, who's pleased to see him. He says his Tupperware "talisman" will slay Grendle, but out pops Unferth the Totally Uncool, and says the talisman must be some sort of evil thing, because the Doctor must be in league with Grendle. He and the Doctor tussle a bit and Freya comes to the Doctor's aid. If only she knew this is rarely a good idea for women on Star Trek, particularly when they're guest stars! Anyway, Unferth stabs her before grabbing the talisman and running off. She dies in the Doctor's arms, and he takes her sword to the mead hall.

There, he restrains himself from chopping off Unferth's head and calls out for Grendle to show up. The door glows with that light again and the light-tentacled creature appears. The Doctor tries to seem calming and opens the lid of his Tupperware to release the creature, which is still quite fresh, and it joins the mass of tentacles.

Chakotay, Tuvok, and Kim are returned, confused about where they were.

Later in Sickbay, Janeway tells the Doctor she's entering a special commendation in the log for the Doctor's heroism on his first away mission. [Now, this is just the sort of thing captains are supposed to do for their crew, but don't you think it'll draw an odd look or two back at Headquarters?] She wants to cite him by name, but he doesn't want to remember the painful experience of watching Freya die with "Schweitzer" on her lips.

This is fortunate, as it was somewhat painful for me as well -- much as I love this episode.

She tells him that she's sure he'll have more adventures in his life, and we all agree.

CHARACTER
Well, if you've been reading any of my reviews before this one, you probably already know I'm a huge fan of the Doctor, so it's great to see him get some development here. It's also a hint, I think, about the sort of development we can expect from him. The Doctor is not human, not organic, not even composed of a neural network. He is a program, and while he can adapt and learn, he's not going to develop in a way that we've seen before.

In other words, he's not a child. He's inexperienced in some regards, but he assimilates data so fast, and has a vast knowledge of just how awful people can be (from the autopsy files alone) that it's not right to think of him as naive. This is his first time seeing a holographic sky, and the tree is a real thrill, but as long as his program understands its goal, he's not going to be too thrown by novelty, or stare at things with awe, or any of the stuff we've seen from other, similarly non-human characters.

The holodeck, actually, is the perfect place for the Doctor to have an adventure, because while nothing there is "real" to the rest of the crew, it's all as "real" to the Doctor as he is to himself. Freya is his equal, and her death is the end of her. She could be rebooted once the program runs again, but she wouldn't have the same memories, wouldn't be "his" Freya.

So when the Doctor goes into that mead hall, he is both superior in being a more complex program (and being a main character on the show) and an equal for being a program at all. The contrast of his prissy ego and the challenging boasts of the Beowulf are fun, and show the true nature of the Doctor's challenge. He must act more like these characters, however superior his program may be, to win their support.

The thing is, in the end, that he fails at this. Freya is his only real ally, and look what happens to her. The others are only cowed by his sword, and only for a moment at that.

He has more success with the photonic energy being (which is also another way of describing the Doctor, since "photonic energy" means basically "light energy"). The challenge to this creature is far less complicated than the chest-thumping-tell-us-of-your-deeds challenges which make up the entire Grendle story. The photonic creatures both simply want their fellow creatures back.

As for the other characters, I like Janeway's new hairdo.

THOUGHT
Back to the Doctor, the fun of the his adventures relies on watching him eat something for the first time (holographic food, of course) and get knocked around a bit and all the usual things that happen to adventurers. In fact, Kes' warning that the Doctor needs to feel more like a Starfleet officer deserves a little study.

The Doctor has only recently been working on being a "real" member of the crew, and the crew are working on treating him that way. That's why Paris can suggest he go into the holodeck in the first place. In taking on the responsibility of the mission, the Doctor is taking his final place in his crew, and so gets treated to the assorted goodies that come to Starfleet officers on missions. He gets to fight, he gets to kiss the girl, he gets to make first contact, he gets to save the day. He gets, in short, to be Starfleet's version of a hero.

The Beowulf backdrop makes a constant comment on the nature of this heroism. Has it really changed in all these centuries? The challenges of the warriors to each other are really just melodramatic versions of what Chokotay and Paris and Tuvok go through when they look at each other. That this is Kim's program is interesting, considering that he's not treated like one of the big boys on the ship. The Doctor is using Kim's method of pretending he's a warrior to become a hero in actuality, and when he succeeds in "slaying Grendle" he also succeeds in his mission. This is wonderfully displayed when the Doctor announces with great discomfort, "I'm simply a...warrior," and then proceeds to act like the Starfleet version of one. The styles of the Beowulf warriors are different from Starfleet protocol (though they remind me a lot of the Kazon), but the end result is similar. No wonder the Doc gets such a charge out of being cheered by Freya and company. His usual heroism in Sickbay rarely gets a "Thank you."

To help all this out, we get some interesting glimpses into hologram existence. When Unferth tells the king for the second time that it's time to retire, the king responds, "Always with you it is time to sleep!" Even holocharacters, it seems, can get tired of the same old routine.

SPECTACLE
The photonic creature is okay, but the Beowulf sets are great. The mead hall is fire-lit and dusty, the costumes nicely bulky and fleeced (making Freya have to change into a housedress for her nice-nice scene with the Doctor), and the forest dark and chilly.

DICTION
Some good lines in this one include:

"You are a master of many talents, Lord Schweitzer. Your people must value you greatly." "You would think so." -- Freya and the Doctor.

"Your name means nothing to me." -- Unferth to Doctor "Schweitzer" in a cute bit of irony.


SONG
Great music with real musicians!

And now for the baggage...

STAR TREK ELEMENTS WE (OR I, ANYWAY) LOVE
I think sometimes the real reason I watch the show is the made-up cultures. I'll just replay this one in its entirety, including the part from Humanities 101:

Chakotay: "Every culture has its demons. They embody the darkest emotions of its people. Giving them physical form in heroic literature is a way of exploring those feelings. The Vokshaw of Recalla Prime believe that hate is a beast which lives inside the stomach. Their greatest mythical hero is a man who ate stones for 23 days to kill the beast and became a saint."

Tuvok: Such fables are necessary only in cultures which unduly emphasize emotions. I would point out that there are no demons in Vulcan literature."

Chakotay: "That might account for its popularity."

I also love it when they remember details like beaming in the tricorder to the holodeck.

STAR TREK ELEMENTS WE (OR I, ANYWAY) HATE
Hmmm, did she have to die with such willing self-sacrifice? At least she didn't give birth to his son first.

Well, that's the end of my saga.

Star Trek Voyager Reviews

Or forward you can go to ST Voyager Reviews -- Cathexis.

Or back to ST Voyager Reviews -- State of Flux.