Star Trek Voyager Reviews Written by Someone Who Actually LIKES the Show! -- Jetrel


Hello there. This is a review of the Star Trek Voyager epsiode, "Jetrel." It's full of spoilers and expressly intended for the enjoyment and consideration of Voyager fans, and for those who enjoy contemplating the dangers of science applied without a conscience. Those of you who'd rather do anything else than learn about Neelix's childhood, may I suggest you get some valuable educational experience?

How about, say, at On-Line English Grammar?

That ain't for you? Okay then, but be warned, Neelix is the main character.

INITIAL VIEWER EXPERIENCE
Hmmm, I can feel the moral coming at me...Resistance is futile! You will be sermonized!...Actually, though, this does help to explain a lot about Voyager's little munchkin...Jetrel is actually making me feel sad...Ew! what's in the container?!

PLOT
After learning about shooting a "safety" at pool with Tuvok, Paris, and that annoying thin guy at Sandrine's, Neelix is contacted by a Hacconian shuttle. The Talaxians were conquered by the Hacconians fifteen years ago, so this doesn't exactly make his day. In fact, when he finds out exactly who is calling him, Dr. Jetrel, he runs off the bridge as though he's about to vomit.

Neelix explains to Janeway that Jetrel is the scientist who invented to Metrion Cascade, a doomsday weapon that caused indescribable damage to Rinax, a moon of Neelix's homeworld, Talax. Over 300,000 Talaxians were killed, including all of Neelix' family. Neelix himself only escaped because he was down on Talaxia at the time with the defense forces. He was part of the rescue teams which went to the moon afterwards, however, and he saw first-hand the horrible destruction.

Jetrel, who is fascinated by Voyager's transporters, comes aboard, and Janeway tells him that Neelix isn't interested in helping him with anything. Jetrel explains that many people who were exposed to the Metrion Cascade's fall-out now suffer from metremia, a fatal form of radiation poisoning. He wants to screen Neelix for it.

Kes and Neelix talk about how they've never discussed the war, and Janeway relays the doctor's request. No way, he says, but they talk him into at least meeting with Jetrel.

This meeting is something less than a total success. Neelix mostly uses it to make Jetrel feel as bad about his role in the war as possible. Jetrel, who obviously feels bad enough already, doesn't put up much of an argument. Finally, Neelix says he'd rather die than help Jetrel, and the scientist responds, "Isn't helping other Talaxians more important than punishing me?" Neelix has to think about it.

Jetrel scans Neelix and discovers that he does indeed have the disease. Neelix tells Kes a story about how he tried to kill some vermin on his homeworld once, then felt bad about it. Alone with him in his room later, Kes worries about Neelix, and he responds that at least now he'll die before she will and he won't feel so alone without her. She wants to cherish every minute they have.

Jetrel tells Janeway that her transporters might be able to help him find a cure for the disease. If they could go to Rinax and beam some of the Metrion cloud aboard, he could study it more closely than he's been able to so far. Though it means a significance detour for the ship, she agrees to go. On the way out of the ready room, Jetrel has a small attack which he says is nothing. [On Star Trek, however, we immediately know such illnesses are never "nothing."]

Kes gets Neelix to keep working with Jetrel, who watches with interest as the Doctor turns himself off. Alone, Jetrel and Neelix now engage in a lengthy and thinly-veiled Hiroshima discussion full of military strategy and finger-pointing. Jetrel reveals that he lost his wife and family to divorce after the war because they thought him a monster. Neelix tells the story of going to Rinax after the explosion and seeing a burned little girl, Polaxia. Jetrel cries and Neelix rubs more salt into the wound, asking, "Did you ever think that your wife was right, that you had become a monster?" Jetrel responds, "Yes." In fact, as soon as he saw the first test of the cascade, that blinding light, he knew that he had become death. Neelix wants him to live with the knowledge of that for a long time, but Jetrel breaks the news that he's dying of Metremia and will be dead in days. [I told you it wasn't "nothing."]

Neelix has a scary dream with all the usual accusatory images, and is awakened by the news that they've arrived at Rinax. Neelix goes to the bridge and sees the cloud-covered, gray, and lifeless planet on the viewscreen, then talks about looking up in the sky to see the light of the cascade. Torres brings up a sample of the cloud for Jetrel, who takes it to Sickbay and turns off the Doctor.

Neelix, meanwhile, has curled up into a ball of pain in the mess hall. Kes finds him and he confesses that he wasn't off Rinax when the weapon hit because he was with the resistance, but because he was trying to avoid the fighting all together. He didn't want to be at war with anyone. His pacifism now strikes him as cowardice, and he blames himself for still being alive when his family is all dead. Kes asks him if the real reason he hates Jetrel so much is because he's mad at himself.

Jetrel has done some sort of experiment on the cloud vapors to turn them into goo which moves inside the container as though alive. Neelix, wanting to talk, interrupts this and gets tranquilized. Jetrel heads for the transporter room.

Janeway reactivates the Doctor, who finds Neelix. She and Neelix go to the transporter room with Tuvok and some security people, convinced he's performing some sort of misdeed with the transporter. Jetrel reveals instead that the transporter might be used to rematerialize the victims of the cascade. The cloud of atomized matter has actually been keeping the victim's patterns in a semi-tractable fashion. The transporter could search for a specific DNA pattern and put people back together. This has been his goal all along. Neelix, in fact, doesn't even have the disease. Janeway is highly skeptical this could ever work, but allows him to try.

It's a good effort, but it just won't fly. Jetrel collapses with the disappointment.

In Sickbay, Neelix realizes the cascade was a punishment for both sides in the war and offers Jetrel his forgiveness. Jetrel dies on cue.

CHARACTER
This is the sort of episode that wasn't terribly fun to watch, but does give us a lot to think about, though not necessarily with the A-bomb stuff. If considering the tragedy of Hiroshima and Nagaski are new to you, hey, knock yourself out. There's plenty of guilt from WWII to go around. But if you're tired of that, there are other things to consider instead.

Neelix's character has been a puzzle to me for some time now. He seems so damned positive all the time. He's like one of those people who boom out, "Always great!" when you've done nothing more than ask them how they are. Listening to him prattle away, it's easy to wonder if he's ever had a real feeling in his whole life.

Well, we get that question answered here in spades, and I think it makes sense. Neelix's past is so horrific, so inconceivably awful, that he has decided to focus on the positives of the future to the point of repression. Neelix's avoidance of the war issue with Kes and the many lies he's told her about his prowess in battle effectively reveal that he hasn't allowed himself to deal with his own past. This may not strike you as terribly original, but when you get down to it, who really has an original neurosis these days, apart from the fetishes of some sadistic serial murderers? Neelix's emotional problems are all too familiar: he's so damn cheerful because he can't handle his own sorrow. He's got a smile on his face because he refuses to feel bad. No wonder it makes him so annoying. No wonder it renders him so insensitive to others' discomfort. He doesn't listen to his own bad feelings, so how can he hear those from other people?

And what I really like is that this episode doesn't magically cure him of that. His forgiveness of Jetrel is the sort of symbolic offering we make after a huge emotional outpouring makes us feel renewed, but it hardly begins to heal the wounds of Polaxia and his dead family. He has come to better terms with his suffering, but he's still not going to be able to deal with it on a day-to-day basis. Doubtlessly he'll continue to be the same toady nicely-nicely guy we've all come to know so well. But it will make an interesting character goal for him to become better at dealing with his own more negative qualities, if the writers really pursue the implications of this episode.

So Neelix exorcises his anger upon Jetrel, and Jetrel, who is a truly pathetic figure here, can do nothing, not even apologize, for what he has done. His scientific defenses all seem true enough, but it's clear he doesn't believe in them anymore himself. Jetrel nicely represents another "casualty" of war. He may be blameless for the cascade. He invented it, but he didn't drop it. He made the inevitable scientific discovery, but he didn't cause the war. He this and he that.

What's important in the end for Jetrel, however, is simply that he was involved. His guilt, whether deserved or not, simply exists, and would exist in anyone with a conscience no matter what arguments were used against it. He cannot live with what his machine has done, and so he spends the last fifteen years of his life trying to undo the damage.

And this is the best bit: in pursuing that goal of undoing, he is just as obsessive as he ever was in making the weapon in the first place. Just what, I want to know, is in that goo he makes in Sickbay? Through that sort of pain does he put the victim on the transporter pad while he tries to rematerialize him? Why doesn't he just ask to use the transporter for his experiment in the first place? Jetrel has a need to finish, to be right, to be able to undo the cascade. This science-oriented obsession is part of what makes up Jetrel's fundamental nature, and yet we applaud it when he's working on something we like, and shun it when he's not.

In the end, Neelix's forgiveness matters little to Jetrel, I think, though it may mean the small beginning of a new life for Neelix. Time will tell.

THOUGHT
Whoops, I think all my THOUGHT stuff went into CHARACTER today.


SPECTACLE
That moving goo is really awful. Does anyone else remember the comic book about the guy who can't die, and keeps trying to kill himself, and finally gets all chopped up and is still alive? Yuck.

DICTION
I already mentioned it, but Neelix really shows how cruel he can be when he's got his own obsession going with the line: "Did you every think that maybe your wife was right, that you had become a monster?"


SONG
Great music, as always, performed splendidly by a real orchestra.

And now for the baggage...

STAR TREK ELEMENTS WE (OR I, ANYWAY) LOVE
Character development is my favorite part, and I'm noticing that on Voyager we're getting some really elaborate development, with some of the characters, anyway. The writers seem to want to give us more than throw-away traits like Data's inability to make contractions [Why? I ask you! Why?], and LaForge's difficulty in getting women. Character development is coming out of childhood stories, directed efforts at self-improvement, philosophical differences, and genuine crew friction. It hasn't really all come together yet, but it's fun to watch.

STAR TREK ELEMENTS WE (OR I, ANYWAY) HATE
Much as I love Star Trek's ability to reflect our own culture through allegory, sometimes it gets really irritating. All the Hiroshima references are extremely annoying. One would have sufficed. We didn't need the bright light, the scientist having a revelation at the test site, etc. Frankly, it gets distracting.

Well, I've come to the end of another one.

Star Trek Voyager Reviews

ST Voyager Review - Learning Curve

Or go back to ST Voyager Reviews -- Faces.