Finally! We learn about Chakotay's tribe and why he wears that tattoo [Hence the title!] on his face (not that one needs a reason per se, but it's nice to have one). And in this spoiler-filled review of Star Trek Voyager's episode, "Tattoo," I'm going to talk all about one of our favorite first officers. I'm doing this solely for the enjoyment of my fellow Voyager fans, and in the hope of getting some nice e-mail, so if facial tattoos are too much for you, why don't you go look at some more traditional art?
A place you might enjoy would be Etiquette Hell.
No? Okay, then...
INITIAL VIEWER EXPERIENCE
Well, I have been begging for some more Chakotay development, and we're certainly seeing a new side to him...Hey! that's Zorro's dad!...So, just like with Paris, Janeway, Torres, and Kes (and the Doctor), Chakotay's personality was formed by his father. Do they have mothers at all?...Ah, yet another race can teach us about peace and brotherhood.
PLOT
Torres, Chakotay, Tuvok, Neelix, and some extras are surveying a rocky moon for some polytheranide for the nacelles. Neelix and Tuvok show Chakotay a spiral-like drawing on the ground, and this sends him into a flashback. As a fifteen-year-old, Chakotay walks through a Central American jungle with his father, Kolopak, looking for the tribe of the Rubber Tree People (his father's idea). Young Chakotay finds a symbol very similar to the one Neelix and Tuvok found. His father explains that it's a healing symbol of the Rubber Tree People. Chakotay is himself a descendant of these Rubber Tree People, though that does nothing to make the Young Chakotay any more interested in this field trip. Why would anyone choose to live in a jungle? he wants to know.
On Voyager, Wildman is trying to get the Doctor to help her with lower back pain caused by her pregnancy, but he's unsympathetic in the extreme. Kes tsk-tsks him for being so unfeeling. She credits his own lack of first-hand experience with illness, and wishes that for once in his life he could know how bad feeling bad feels. Alone, he comments, "I don't have a life, I have a program." Nonetheless, Kes' words seem to have given him an idea.
Chakotay tells Janeway about his trip to Central America with his father and shows her the similarities between the symbol he saw then and the one from today. She asks if he has an explanation, and, scoffing, he tells her of his tribe's ancient legend of the Sky Spirits who came to Earth to create the Rubber Tree People. He says he puts no more faith in this story than she does in Adam and Eve [see THOUGHT]. However, he is curious about the symbol.
Janeway tells him about the warp trail they've found leading away from the moon. She figures if the people who drew the symbol know warp technology, they might also know where they can lay their hands on some polytheranide. So Voyager follows the trail to a seemingly lifeless planet which shows signs of an of energy source. Janeway sends an unanswered hail, and Chakotay assembles his away team in the transporter room.
Where they are stymied. It seems every time Torres fixes on a site to beam down to the surface, a storm appears right over that site. They figure that maybe their transporter beam is causing an atmospheric disturbance (proving that even Starfleet officers can be blind to things they don't want to see), and Chakotay decides to take a shuttle down. In the shuttle, however, they have to deal with another lightning storm and more annoying comments from Neelix.
Chakotay has another flashback to when he was watching it rain in the Central American rain forest. He hates the bugs, and hates the whole trip, but Kolopak is worried that his son will lose his way if he doesn't have the spirits to guide him.
Present-day Chakotay looks out the window of the shuttle and sees a face in the clouds.
Kes activates the EMH, and the Doctor greets her with "Please state the nature of the medical emergency." He's taken up his old phrase because it "works" for him. He then sneezes and explains that he's programmed himself to mimic all the symptoms of the 20-hour Levodian 'flu. He blows his holographic runny nose on some holographic tissue (and hopefully throws it in a holographic trash can, but I didn't see for certain) and calls being sick an "interesting experience." It seems he's set this all up so that he can serve as an example to the crew of how to keep in good spirits even when ill.
Can you say, "Ain't gonna happen?"
Chakotay really digs the jungle down on the planet. It reminds him of the Central American forest. There's even a species of flower there which looks decidedly Terran. Tuvok knows all about the flower, and it turns out that he is a breeder of orchids. Neelix is delighted to learn this, as he breeds orchids as well -- they make good eatin'! Tuvok's nostrils flare.
Torres tells Chakotay that the polytheranide is there, but that they will have to mine it very carefully. They look up to see a hawk, and this triggers another flashback.
It seems that on this little trip through the jungle, Chakotay looks at a similar hawk and is asked by his father if he can hear it. Instead of listening to the hawk, he tells Kolopak about wanting to leave the colony because it's such a drag. In fact, he wants to join Starfleet Academy, and has gotten a sponsorship from Captain Sulu. Kolopak warns Grasshopper that he will be caught between the two cultures for the rest of his life. In the middle of this, they stumble across en empty dwelling site.
Neelix signals Chakotay that he's found something, but then starts screaming in pain. Chakotay and Torres run to Neelix, and find that he's been attacked by that hawk. Voyager has no trouble beaming Neelix to Sickbay, and Tuvok shows up to lead Chakotay and Torres to an empty dwelling site.
Neelix is treated by a hoarse Doctor who insists that he wants no compassion. The illness -- achoo! -- is not bad.
The ship is ready to start mining, and Janeway asks Chakotay if they've made any progress contacting the people on this planet. Chakotay tells her about the face he's been seeing in the clouds, and after her experience in "Persistence of Vision," Janeway doesn't suggest that her first officer spend less time with his hallucinogenic device.
Chakotay has Torres and Tuvok put down their phasers, though Tuvok objects strongly. Chakotay is too busy having a flashback to care. It seems his father had their expedition team set down their weapons to let the Rubber Tree People know they came in peace,
[And now if you'll allow me, I'd like to take advantage of the Internet to ask anyone reading this if they know whether we really have Rubber Tree People on Earth, or if this is all made up by Star Trek. Please e-mail me if you know anything about it, and I'll put it in the review.]
In simple clothes and tattoos on their faces just like Chakotay's, The Rubber Tree People do come out of hiding, and there's a tense moment when one of the men (there are no women in the expedition) moves towards their weapons. One of the Rubber Tree People, throws a spear, but Kolopak draws that symbol in the sand and even knows the Rubber Tree People's language. The Chief tells him, "We are of the same hand," and throws the spear away and all the Rubber Tree babes come out with beer and chips. Soon, someone's got the volley-ball net up and they're having a swinging good time.
Present-day Chakotay gets nothing for his trouble but a big wind storm. He calls for everyone to run to the shuttle, but he gets separated from Tuvok and Torres when he catches sight of a skinny man in the trees. Tuvok and Torres finally call for an emergency beam-out, but Chakotay has been knocked down (and his combadge knocked off) by a falling tree.
Holding Chakotay's retrieved combadge, Janeway is told that scans can no longer find Chakotay or the shuttle. She gets ready to lead another away team, but the Doctor calls for her in desperation. It seems something has gone horribly wrong with his little experiment, and his 'flu has lasted an hour longer than it should have. Janeway needs Kes for the away team, but she sends Kim to look at the Doctor's computer. In Sickbay, Kes is comforting the pathetic Doctor, but when Kim arrives she explains that she reprogrammed the Doctor's 'flu to make it last longer. It wasn't really a fair test, she says, when he knew exactly when it would be over. The Doctor tells Kim, "She far more devious that I ever suspected."
Chakotay wakes up without his combadge and does a tricorder scan. He realizes he's alone with no shuttle and walks back to the empty dwelling site. There, he tells the trees that he means no harm, then takes off his clothes.
This singular maneuver is explained with another flashback. His father's expedition take off their clothes and put on Rubber Tree clothes -- except for sulky Chakotay, of course. He just watches in moping silence as the Rubber Tree People paint a sign just like their tattoos on Kolopak's face.
Chakotay stands naked in the dwelling and says he wants to talk [insert Dumb Blonde joke here]. He finds simple garments on a bench and puts them on.
In the transporter room, Voyager's away team once again has trouble with those storms, and Tuvok finally points out that the weather seems to be controlled by people who do not want Voyager to bother them. They let the transporter take people away, but not bring them down. Janeway says she'd be happy to leave these people alone, but she needs to get Chakotay back. She tells Paris to land the ship, but the atmosphere once again treats them to a storm.
Chakotay gets out of the storm by dodging lightning and running into a cave.
Voyager gets caught in a full-blown cyclone. Impulse engines are off-line, and with inertial dampers off-line, they can't go to warp. In about ten minutes, they'll crash.
Chakotay hears Rubber Tree speech in the cave, but doesn't know the language. People appear and Chakotay gives them the one word he knows from his father, sort of the Rubber Tree version of "shalome." These people have alien foreheads complete with Rubber Tree own tattoo.
We see further indication that Voyager's gonna crash!
The leader holds Chakotay's hand and now they can talk. The leader asks about Chakotay's tattoo and he explains that he wears it to honor his father, who wore it to honor his ancestors.
It turns out these people are indeed the Sky Spirits. They came to Earth the first time 45,000 years ago and found a nomadic Eskimo tribe. They gave them some gifts, including a kind of cultural race memory, the faintest traces of which are in Chakotay (hence, I think, the face in the sky, but I'm not sure). This tribe grew a very strong culture and migrated to the rain forest. These people visited Earth several times (though the journey to Earth takes them two generations) to check on the tribe, but on the last visit thought that all the descendants of them had been destroyed by condominium developers and Pepsi-Cola ads. Chakotay says that in fact some did survive and Earth's a much nicer place these days (everyone only drinks the Uncola).
The storms have all been an attempt to keep these Earth people with no respect for the land off their world, but Chakotay assures the aliens again that Voyager's crew is better than they fear.
Voyager is a thousand meters from impact, and Paris is looking frustrated indeed, then, with ten seconds before impact, the weather clears right up. Paris gets them back into orbit, and Tuvok now reads a population of people on the planet. They scan for Chakotay.
Chakotay is talking to the leader in the dwelling site now. It seems the Sky Spirits will give Voyager some of the mineral they need. Chakotay tells him that his father died fighting Cardassia, and that's why he joined the Maquis and got the tattoo. He and his dad were on bad terms when he died, and though Chakotay has tried on many visionquests to talk to his father, Kolopak never answered...until now.
The leader draws the symbol in the ground as Torres, Kes, and Tuvok enter with weapons drawn. Embarrassed for his people, Chakotay hisses at them to put their weapons away, then gives the leader a big ole hug.
The hawk goes overhead and Chakotay tells his father that he finally hears him.
And the away team beams up.
CHARACTER
We have an interesting type of character development here, a careful elaboration of this pivotal moment in Chakotay's life that explains about a hundred different things he's done or said since the show started. And yet, does it really? The really pivotal moment seems to be his father's death, which changed the way he perceived this field trip. Chakotay at fifteen hates the whole thing and seems quite unaffected by his father's joyous discovery of the Rubber Tree People. We see the tattoo, and the lessons Kolopak taught him about respecting people's culture, but what happened to make him actually put these lessons to use?
Why, his father's death, of course.
Well, sorry, but that's not enough for me. This episode is a good start, but I want more. Are we to understand that his entire life changed from good Starfleet officer and sneerer at people's cultures to Mr. Maquis/I'll Respect Your Culture to My Death simply because he feels guilty over his relationship with his father? That's a lot of guilt.
And then, if he's got so much respect for people's culture as we've seen in the show, why does he have no faith whatsoever in the Sky Spirits? I notice he never did learn the tongue of his ancestors, and surely someone who was truly trying to embrace his culture would at least learn a bit of it. His scientific orientation, I understand, keeps him from believing Sky Spirits created the Rubber Tree People, but shouldn't he think that maybe there's something else to them? It seems so inconsistent.
But then, thinking over his character as we've gotten it so far, Chakotay has displayed this inconsistency before. There's a strangely scientific grounding for all his rituals which keeps them from really seeming religious. In many ways, discovering that the Sky Spirits are a group of aliens is perfect for Chakotay. No wonder he can now "hear" the hawk. The faith of his people has been transmuted into scientifically provable history. Chakotay hasn't really changed at the end of the story; the universe has changed to accommodate him.
So despite the show's assertion that Chakotay has had some major insight here ("I can hear the hawk)", it's not really character-building for him. Perhaps Chakotay offers us a sort of paradox. Since he so matter-of-factly embraces the rituals of his people, they seem to have lost their magic, or their miracle, for him. He is a great one for ceremony, but not much of a one for faith.
It's nice to see that the ground in which Tuvok and Chakotay buried the hatchet in "Twisted" was very shallow indeed. I wonder if Tuvok might wait until he has Pon Farr for an excuse and then jump Chakotay in the turbo-lift with a knife, screaming "I take exception to you!"
I'm sure we all saw Kes' trick on the Doctor coming from a mile away, but it is a valuable lesson for him to learn, and should believably make him more compassionate in future. In fact, not having experienced illness is a major oversight in his programming.
Well, not for a short-term emergency supplement, I suppose. But definitely for someone who wants to be a "real" doctor. His treatment of Ensign Wildman reminds me of a few doctors and nurses I've run into in my life. ("It will only hurt more if you move", "It's not that cold", "Hmmm, I can't seem to find a vein.") I've certainly wished illness on a few medical practitioners over the years.
As for Kes, last week we learned she's powerful, and this week we get that she's devious. What are the writers setting us up for?
THOUGHT
Finding out that the Sky Spirits are aliens fits Star Trek as well as it fits Chakotay, which brings out something of an inconsistency in the show as well.
Now, I know talking about religion makes people nervous, so I'll try to be careful. If that's not enough for you, please skip down seven paragraphs to SPECTACLE, because I am going to mention some religions by name.
Star Trek is constantly harping on cultural awareness and respect. Hey, that's one of the reasons I watch the show. We've seen Star Trek demand that we respect Trill, Klingon, Romulan, Ferengi, Easter Bunny, Betazoid, Younameit cultures and ideals and beliefs. And yet sometimes the show isn't careful to respect Christian ideals. [I can't think of a time they've stomped on Jewish or Hindu beliefs, but that may be because I'm not as sensitive to them. My point would work equally well for any religion, however, which requires any faith in or respect for creation theory.] Now, don't get me wrong, I'm not talking about everyone holding hands in prayer or anything. I don't want to see Christian ceremonies or any real liturgical practices upheld on the show, unless it were actually a part of the plot or something. And while peace and brotherhood and all that are a part of Christian faith, I don't think anyone should lay any Christian claims to them. Peace and brotherhood are the cornerstone to a lot of faiths these days. Peace and brotherhood can be Sky Spirit and Rubber Tree People ideals without, I should think, anyone in their right mind saying anything but "Right on!"
But sometimes...
Take "The Chase," for example. We're given this proto-culture that went around putting their DNA in lifeforms all over the galaxy so they wouldn't be forgotten. No more life evolving independently on Earth. No more...well, no more a lot of things if we're to take it seriously.
Now, this was supposed to explain why there are all these humanoids in the Alpha Quadrant who can reproduce with each other. Of course, now we find there are all these humanoids in the Delta and Gamma Quadrants, and in general this amazing discovery Picard and company made seems to have had no real impact on the inter-stellar community. Does the 24th Century regard this archeological find with the same skepticism we view the lost city of Atlantis? In any event, the whole Trek series seems uncomfortable with the repercussions of this episode's allegations, and the whole thing hasn't been mentioned since.
And now in "Tattoo" we get Chakotay's casual knock of the Adam and Eve story. Now, I understand Chakotay couldn't go for that story, but the way he puts it implies that no one in the 24th Century does. That doesn't sound like respecting cultural diversity to me.
So I'm going to assume (and it's a big assumption, I'll grant you) that Chakotay might regret the ease with which he tosses off that Adam and Eve phrase after his encounter with the Sky Spirits. Ancient legends seem once again to have their basis in fact. Perhaps we are even being asked to reconsider our own approach to the ancient legends of our religions. I'd like to think so.
As long as I'm not supposed to think Adam and Eve may have come from Mars, or anything.
SPECTACLE
Make-up does a nice job giving us alien foreheads that work well with Chakotay's tattoo.
The ship spiraling down in the cyclone looks truly dire. Nice storm.
The face in the clouds reminds me of a hundred really bad postcards of the type sold in Meteor City.
DICTION
Good lines include:
"Compassion can be your department. Fortunately, you have enough for both of us." -- the Doctor to Kes.
"Put those away!" -- Chakotay to the armed away team.
![]()
SONG
Great music performed by real musicians, especially good in the cyclone.
And now for the baggage...
STAR TREK ELEMENTS WE (OR I, ANYWAY) LOVE
It's always a hoot when Star Trek technologies make sense. Kim suggests going to warp to get them out of the cyclone, and Paris reminds us all, "Without inertial dampeners the ship might make it out okay, but we'd all just be stains on the back wall." This sort of talk -- as different from technobabble as can be -- really helps us believe the ship is in danger, even more than Nurse Chapel's -- I mean the computer's warnings that their approach vector to the surface is too steep.
STAR TREK ELEMENTS WE (OR I, ANYWAY) HATE
See THOUGHT.
Well, that's all for now!
Star Trek Voyager Reviews
Or bravely go on ahead to ST Voyager Reviews -- Cold Fire.
Or chicken on back to ST Voyager Reviews -- Persistence of Vision.